Re: wow - Julia Roberts is just amazing
by
lucabrasi
12/30/2007, 10:54 AM #
It is an interestingly different role for Roberts.
I didn't get out the stopwatch, but it felt like she had much less screen time than Hanks OR, more significantly Philip Seymour Hoffman. It was more like a male-buddy movie in which the "guest star woman" floats in and out at key points.
Still, Joanne is vital to the story and Roberts' patented Steel Magnolia-intensity of righteousness and indignation was tempered with a certain amusing haughteur.
Roberts played poor in "Erin Brockovich"; here, she's playing ultra-rich. So the indignation has to emanate from a different source: political commitment and fervent anti-Communism. The demonstrably liberal Democrat Roberts playing a demonstrably conservative Republican doyenne has the natural tension of such performances, btw. Its literally hard to believe. A similar problem befell Richard Dreyfuss playing the conservative Rep vs. Michael Douglas Demo in "The American President." (Wasn't that movie also written by Aaron Sorkin?) But it is hard to find ranking Republican movie stars. Even Bruce Willis swears he's an independent, now.
Something amusing early in the movie. Julia Roberts has said that her fans don't want her in bedroom sex scenes, but rather only want to see her "the morning after, in bed with my hair tousled."
Roberts and Hanks have an early sexual liasion in "Charlie Wilson's War" in which we never even SEE them in bed. It is as if our two ranking long-term superstars would never even think to allow us to view such a Royal Coupling. However, we seem them afterwards in Joanne's luxurious bathroom, with Hanks (amusingly) being the naked one -- in the bathtub. Roberts sits at a table doing her eyelashes...with a safety pin!...and reciting a lenghty political-technical speech with the aplomb of an Oscar winning star, as if to show us, "here, see, JULIA ROBERTS can rattle off one of these four-page long tech-talk speeches," too.
Later in the film, Roberts gets a lengthy dialogue scene with Philip Seymour Hoffman that seems shoehorned into the movie simply so that they get a scene together. But it is amusing on its star terms: yes, I, Julia Roberts, will show my ability to hold the screen with this Indiefilm whizkid, Mr. Hoffman. C'mon, kid, I can take it. Laura Linney's nowhere around, buddy, its you and me.
The political ramifications and realities of "Charlie Wilson's War" seem to be almost beside the point for that movie, which may be bad for its serious pretensions, but good for its ultimate role of service: to showcase three movie stars doing what they do best, and showing us WHY they are three ranking movie stars (of which two, however, are only truly bankable, but that doesn't matter here.)