Go to Ask.com


enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Dems "sell" citizenship?
by SlaterBait
+1/-2 Reply

Reported today is a claim that the average family paid $10 more for Thanksgiving dinner because of the crackdown on illegal immigration. Word is that the majority of farm workers are illegal and that replacing them with U.S. citizens is expensive.... citizens supposedly won't work so cheap!

So Senator Diane Finestein (D-CA) is to offer a bill offering citizenship to farm workers after 3 to 5 years in the fields.

I guess the PRICE of citizenship is the difference between what these illegals charge vs the price legals charge. Say they work for $6/hr vs $12/hr... and assume we require 4 years... so the upper limit of the cost of citizenship in Senator Finestein's mind is: 2000 hr/yr * 4 yrs * $6 = $48,000.

Now that number might not be accurate, but the GAO will certainly be asked to compute the actual "value" of a citizenship based upon the Senator's proposal and the various amendments that will certainly be offered.

I guess rich aliens can by-pass the work requirement by simply paying the $48,000 up front. Right?

Now this bit of insanity is supposedly a "good idea" because it keeps the cost of food down.... something especially important to the low-wage workers who are unwilling to take on these jobs that illegals will do!

(I suspect that at least part of the reason citizens won't work for the wages paid to illegals because CITIZENS have to pay FICA taxes as well as taxes on income, property, gasoline, heating oil/gas, water/sewage, electricity, phones, etc. ...but this is beside the point, apparently.)

Also, consider this....

Once the first crop of illegal farm workers complete their enslavement (i.e. become citizens through their working in the fields) we'll have to import a new crop of illegals to replace them.

ONCE THEY BECOME CITIZENS, THEY TOO WILL NOT DO THIS WORK SO CHEAPLY! ...after all, they'll have to pay taxes and fees for those homes, cars, phones, etc.

INSANITY! With this type of thinking in Washington (and California) it is a wonder we ever fought the Civil War!

Heck, all we HAD to do was to promise that every slave would be given citizenship once they were no longer able to work in the fields! The plantation owners would LOVE this! Once the slaves became old, rather than keeping them on the plantation as "Uncle Toms", the plantation owners could declare them citizens, put them out on welfare and let the government house and feed them.... and think of how cheap food would be!

<<< extreme sarcasm >>>

Idea: why not pay U.S. citizens enough to do this work? It would be cheaper in the long run since we will not have to keep importing illegals to keep prices down!

Vote for sanity in Washington. Do not re-elect an incumbent. Consider voting for REAL change!

While GOP says "...citizenship NOT REQUIRED...
by Qtec90

...to come take even the BEST PAYING "US Jobs"!!!

The idea of "GUEST WORKERS" was REVIVED by non-other-then RICK PERRY (R) Texas Governor almost IMMEDIATELY after "Coning" the votes of the rightwing with an election ad campaign about how TUFF he would BE on that topic!!!

REMEMBER that with a "Guest Worker Program" we are NO LONGER talking about jobs that Americans DON’T WANT! ... Mexico has College Educated Professionals TOO that would JUMP at legal jobs in the US that pay MORE then they are currently getting but FAR LESS then what an American would expect to be paid. PLUS the "Illegal Flow" that in all respects would not be very much effected in actual application or practice.

Just as much as it’s a "Fantasy" at the very best to think that the "Bush’s Immigration Program" will have ANY real impact upon the flow of illegal immigrants from across the boarder (EXCEPT it WILL add LEGAL non-American workers to those illegal workers thereby driving wages earned by American workers down EVEN FURTHER especially in border states!), a "US / MEXICO FENCE" would have as much more real FUNCTIONALITY then really EXPENSIVE example of "Pop-art".

Diane Feinstein's Citizenship Should Be Revoked
by PaulB
and she should be made to work in the California farms fields picking strawberries for 3 to 5 years to earn it back.
Re: Diane Feinstein's Citizenship Should Be Revoked
by syntax
LOVE that idea! She's definitely more brawn than brain.....and she ain't all that brawny.
citizenship is the last thing it's about
by OneTokeUnder

The baptized-by-Feinstein illegals will be, in four years, as children to Feinstein, just as those who, merely by accident or miracle of birth, never needed to be baptized and who are out of work and who are already dependant upon Feinstein are; it makes no difference that Feinstein plans to put the baptized to work representing her ability to gerrymander.

Feinstein would institutionalize the buying/creating of children. This product is not a natural enemy of, or even a threat to, the vision some people have of Jews drinking Christian childrens' blood.

Re: Dems "sell" citizenship?
by RogueState2
Good luck getting high schoolers and college kids to work on the farms during their "summer recess" (as it was meant to originally).
View as RSS news feed in XML