You are wrong, but I won't say you lied
by
blueshift
10/12/2007, 2:21 PM #
First, I'm pretty sure its only in the UK not other european
countries that the film is shown in science classes (per government
order). There are factual inaccuracies yes, but if you look at
the ruling they are not considered lies per se. For example, the
judge cited the pictures of modern cities being flooded. His beef
is that the flooding is not projected to occur for hundreds of years
and thus it could confuse schoolchildren to see modern day cities
underwater.
Second, we aren't making American school
children watch this movie in a science class, so why would we issue a
clarification to them that the science in it is not perfect?
Your
ice cube example is misleading. Water will rise from two
reasons. First, as the liquid water heats up it will expand
slightly. Secondly and more importantly, much of the ice is
currently locked up on land (not floating in the ocean). When
this ice eventually melts it will flow into the sea and raise ocean
levels.
Finally, you are just wrong about the Vikings and
Greenland. The original explorers used a bit of propaganda to
misdirect others towards greenland while describing iceland as
terrible and uninviting. The smart ones then went to iceland.