enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Here's how Democrats screw small businesses...
by ErictheRight
-1 Reply

By Mike Whalen

Everyone in the full-time political class pays great homage to us entrepreneurs. We are hailed as the "backbone of the American economy" and the "real engine of job creation." Even the liberal wing of the Democratic Party joins in this chorus, carefully differentiating us from that part of the private sector they can successfully publicly disdain as inherently evil. We are the "good" business folks, according to politicians throughout the whole spectrum.

So why are the Congress and the president waging war on the entrepreneurial class with unprecedented zeal, scaring us into a protective hunker-down mode while simultaneously stimulating the economy with matching unprecedented fiscal and monetary inputs? It is like trying to drive a car with one foot floored on the accelerator and one foot hard on the brake. It doesn't work.

The economic war is waged on many fronts. First, let's have a lesson in Taxation 101 for the leaders in political Disneyland. Back in 1986, we had a monster makeover change in the tax code, and one big change effectively encouraged millions of small- and medium-sized businesses to file as Subchapter S corporations, which means the business' income is reported on the individual owner's tax return as personal income. But here comes the zinger, you political Musketeers: That income isn't really the same as our personal income.

Most of us have banking partners who expect to be paid first out of the personal income. Many small- and medium- business owners, like me, actually have significant banking restrictions on our ability to pay ourselves. So when you Musketeers talk about raising taxes on the rich making more than $250,000, you are raising taxes directly on millions of businesses. And yes, that mantra you recite about us creating three-fourths of new jobs is true.

The second foot on the brake is your proposed monster health care taxes that are mainly directed at us. Have you allowed us to pool our buying power through associations or to be able to buy catastrophic health coverage for very young workers as an interim step? No, this isn't about insurance, it is about power.

You've got so many other feet on the brakes. Reinstate the death tax and lots of small and medium owners will need to resume or begin buying life insurance to protect their business instead of investing in new jobs. Brake. You've got our Main Street banker friends scared of your regulators looking up their underwriting with a magnifying glass, so credit is very tough even if the mark-to-market accounting rule has been eased. Brake. "Cap-and-trade." Brake.

I can hear the silent primordial scream of many liberals to these claims; they are thinking that business always claims that every progressive tax and regulation will have adverse consequences and life always goes on just fine. Those entrepreneurs always cry wolf, they're thinking, but the system always absorbs it. I reply, every system has a saturation point, and you've threatened to go well past it.

Snicker if you want. Have you seen the under-24 unemployment rates, especially among minorities? Hey, let's raise the minimum wage to $10 an hour and see who absorbs it and where.

Political class, you've got us entrepreneurs beaten down, discouraged and depressed. Capital may be the engine of entrepreneurial activity, but optimism is the fuel. If you guys just took some of your feet off the brakes, we could do what we entrepreneurs have always done - build stuff and add jobs. Just let us build without fear. If you don't do as I suggest, we will continue to hear of the "jobless recovery" as we entrepreneurs continue to look at your feet on the brakes and ring up "no sale."

Mike Whalen is founder, president and chief executive officer of Heart of America Restaurants and Inns and is policy chairman at the National Center for Policy Analysis.

<link>

And what did I say over a year ago about that minimum wage? I (we) couldn't have been proven any more right.

Re: Here's how Democrats screw small businesses...
by Jen01
small business = a thing of the past
Re: Here's how Democrats screw small businesses...
by partizan


The economic war is waged on many fronts. First, let's have a lesson in Taxation 101 for the leaders in political Disneyland. Back in 1986, we had a monster makeover change in the tax code, and one big change effectively encouraged millions of small- and medium-sized businesses to file as Subchapter S corporations, which means the business' income is reported on the individual owner's tax return as personal income. But here comes the zinger, you political Musketeers: That income isn't really the same as our personal income.

Most of us have banking partners who expect to be paid first out of the personal income. Many small- and medium- business owners, like me, actually have significant banking restrictions on our ability to pay ourselves. So when you Musketeers talk about raising taxes on the rich making more than $250,000, you are raising taxes directly on millions of businesses.

The actual number of business owners who would be affected turns out to be well under a million, and the number of employers would be even less. Based on the number of taxpayers who now report any sort of business income on their returns, the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center projects that 663,608 taxpayers with business income, or business losses, will fall into the top two tax brackets in 2009, when any Obama tax changes would first take effect. Not all of those can properly be called "small-business owners," however. Some are farmers. Many are lawyers, accountants or other professionals who get some of their income in the form of partnership distributions. Others may be passive investors in real-estate partnerships or similar investment arrangements and not really persons who own and manage a business.

It is also not clear how many who report business income actually employ any workers. In 2004, the Tax Policy Center found that hundreds of thousands of individual taxpayers who had business income from partnerships or subchapter-S corporations (whose owners pay taxes as individuals) did not claim any tax deductions for employee expenses. For all these reasons we judge that the actual number of small-business employers who would face higher tax rates under Obama is probably far below 663,608, and certainly a far cry from McCain's ridiculously inflated 23 million figure.

The second foot on the brake is your proposed monster health care taxes that are mainly directed at us. Have you allowed us to pool our buying power through associations or to be able to buy catastrophic health coverage for very young workers as an interim step? No, this isn't about insurance, it is about power. <link>

Reform eliminates price and benefit discrimination against small businesses. A Commonwealth Fund study found the smallest firms pay an average of 18 percent more in health insurance premiums for the same benefits than larger firms. By creating a pool and offering assistance, the House health insurance reform bill will lower small business costs and increase options. Alternatively, those who would rather contribute than offer will have a discrete, predictable contribution and the knowledge that their employees will have decent affordable health care.

<link>

You've got so many other feet on the brakes. Reinstate the death tax and lots of small and medium owners will need to resume or begin buying life insurance to protect their business instead of investing in new jobs. Brake. You've got our Main Street banker friends scared of your regulators looking up their underwriting with a magnifying glass, so credit is very tough even if the mark-to-market accounting rule has been eased. Brake. "Cap-and-trade." Brake.

So much blah blah blah. Everyone should pay taxes on financial gains except those who get theirs from a dead person. How is that right ? Poor Bankers ? The people who when unregulated almost destroyed the economy ? Cry me a river.

Snicker if you want. Have you seen the under-24 unemployment rates, especially among minorities? Hey, let's raise the minimum wage to $10 an hour and see who absorbs it and where.

Oh and its the fault of the minimum wage and not the crashing of the economy.

View as RSS news feed in XML