enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Page 1 of 2 (17 items)   1 2 Next >
Tim McCarver, A National Treasure
by switters
+3 Reply
Tim McCarver rules all.

He's forgotten more about baseball than most people ever knew to begin with. His grasp of the nuances of the game are at next-level-scary proportions, and his working knowledge of field strategy, pitcher-catcher relationships and "position playing" are epic as well.

He makes the simple pleasure of watching baseball on my TV that much more pleasurable. And special.

Tim McCarver is the default poet-warrior of America's favorite pastime. His purple prose flows like Aunt Jemima Pancake Syrup upon the frozen waffles (Eggo brand) of cold statistics that have been warmed in the toaster to a welcoming and comforting golden brown. And baseball history.

He is Lennon to Joe Buck's McCartney; Page to Joe's Plant; Peaches to Joe's Herb; Paula to Joe's Simon.

Tim McCarver is so good that he could just sit there quietly and watch the game and not say anything at all and the game would still be more interesting. He's just that good.

This ain't no alien space zombie from outer space that feeds on human flesh. No way, sir. Not this time. Not even close. (This time it's actually a pre-cambrian overlord sent to our distant future to learn the future ancient art of cheese weaving and then back to the past future to invent deep-fried herring balls. I know, I know, we're still working through all the details.)

Wonderful!

So, from a grateful nation during trying times, I proudly say, Thank you, Tim McCarver. Thank you for what? For being you.
Re: Tim McCarver, A National Treasure
by Schmutzie
"That's the thing about those hard hit line drives at the third baseman. If he catches the ball, the batter is out. But if it gets through, and the left fielder is caught leaning towards center, that ball can roll all the way to the wall and then you're looking at an "extra base hit" for the batter."
I'm not sure this is a good thing (for Timbo), but
by Inkberrow

reading your post I was immediately reminded of all those amusing, ironical snippets---and even books now, I believe---devolving on the idea of Chuch Norris as an all-powerful, all-knowing center of the universe. And yet an everyman nevertheless.

Maybe Chuck vs. Timbo on Celebrity Deathmatch. Timbo could intone Chuck to death before it even got started, explicating the history and groundrules....

When Chuck Norris jumps into a swimming pool...
by RonB52
Bob: If I may shift gears for a moment gentleman, coach Ditka vs. The Hurricane, who would win?

Todd, Pat, Carl: Ditka, Ditka!!

Bob: Hold on, Hold on, Hold on. The name of the Hurricane is Hurricane Ditka.

(Todd begins to pound chest)…..Is everything ok?

Todd: No problem, just having a heart attack. (Pounds Chest)……..Almost over! Done. Done.
Especially special.
by artandsoul
And that Joe Buck, really adds a lot. I mean really. A lot.
he's no tony kubek
by daveto

we had tony kubek for about a decade. i guess after nbc tied a can to his ass we were his only option. man did he hate us, our team, our fans, our city. he was totally pissed, from network tv to the great white wastefuckingland. he couldn't shut up about how useless and ignorant we all were. (it was all true, of course, but we didn't have to hear it every day.) the thing is, people here loved him. because he lent legitimacy to the operation. it was like, we got kubek, pass it around. we stole kubek from nbc, lalalalalala. i just wanted somebody to tell him to shut the fuck up, but the dumbfuck canuck play-by-play guys were even worse than the rest of us. kubek would disagree with everything they said, no matter what, and it was always, yes, tony now i see it, thank you for correcting me, and what a pleasure it is to have you here in toronto. then you'd here tony mutter to himself, christ get off your knees, man, jesus god help me.

i like tim. the thing is, you want the drone, that's what baseball is. it's incredibly boring. so boredom plus boredom times boredom has to equal something. the more nonsensical and irrelevant the story, the better, like a book with no beginning, no middle, no end, just crap, you pick it up and drop it off anywhere you want, it makes no difference.

Speaking of Joe, one of those little pop culture
by Inkberrow
vortices I've been privileged to witness several times: a confirmed non-sports fan, usually a woman, hears a snatch of playoff baseball coverage, or sees his new National car rental commercial, and visibly starts upon the realization that a youngish media personality carries the name "Joe Buck".......visions of Midnight Cowboy swirling in their heads.....
he talks too much.
by MichaelRyerson
Works better
by artandsoul

if one hasn't actually seen him.

We obviously share the same time span on the planet. Or close enough.

Re: he talks too much.
by artandsoul

He's a regular BOTFer.

(not for real)

(well, maybe)

(I don't go there anymore so it could be)

(I have no idea)

"Exactly.
by switters
What's crucial to remember here, for you folks at home watching on TV, is that the ball club that can manage to get more players to cross home plate at the end of 9 innings of play, unless they're tied with an equal number of runs, that ball club wins the game. Incredible! This game has so many levels."
Re: Tim McCarver, A National Treasure
by topazz

Arch also expressed his abiding love for Tim McCarver, here: <link>

heh
by SouthernGal

There seems to be a lot of anti-McCarver folks. Ruminations on A Baboon

FUN & GAMES
The McCarver Drinking Game

Here's how to play:

Get a bottle of your favorite booze and a shot glass and...

1: Drink every time Tim uses a multi-syllable word incorrectly.
2: Drink every time Tim states the obvious like it is a profound insight.
3: Drink every time Tim calls the play wrong.
4: Drink every time Tim gets a player's name wrong.
5: Drink every time one of Tim's inane comments is met with stoney silence by the other broadcasters in the booth.

My guarantee is you'll be drunk by the bottom of the 1st inning!

Now Sports Nut is dead, too?
by switters
Although you have to admit, bacon (and, to a lesser extent, I) tended, under better circumstances, to "bring the party with him/us".

Things might be looking up; I finally got a writer to respond to me over on Green Room. (Hi, Jerry!)

Hope your mom is doing... best as can be expected.
(Fine.) Agree.
by switters
I admit it: I do like Tim. He brings a certain innocence back to the game which the game has irretrievably lost. He's like this big little kid, too excited to contain himself. It can be contagious.

And he caught Bob Gibson, for heaven's sake!

Plus, I love to imagine Joe's facial expressions when Tim blurts out something particularly and beautifully irrelevant. I picture Joe just sitting there, exhaling a bit, shaking his head slightly back and forth. Dreamy.

Needless to say, I'll be pulling for Philly tonight. I'd like 7 games.

(Hi back.)
Page 1 of 2 (17 items)   1 2 Next >
View as RSS news feed in XML