enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
In for a penny, in for a pound
by revrick
+2 Reply

Sen. Olympia Snowe, by casting her vote in favor of the Senate Finance committee version of health care (insurance) reform, has well and truly committed herself to whatever bill the Democrats may choose to pass. She may protest that 'her vote today is her vote today,' but the internal logic of her own assertions will drive her to embrace (drum roll, please) the public option.

Sen Snowe cannot unring the bell of her claims that 'when history calls, history calls,' and that this is a matter of national 'urgency,' without looking either foolish or petty and petulant. Economists may argue that we should let go of 'sunk costs,' but in real life, that's not such an easy thing to do.

In this case, Sen. Snowe's sunk cost is her vote in favor. But she faces some real barriers, both internally and externally, to reversing her choice to throw in her lot with the Democrats. The internal barrier is the sense of shame she would feel, if, after saying that this is a matter of great national importance, she turns around and votes, "NO," on the final bill, thus looking like a spoiled child who threw a fit when she didn't get her way. Moreover, she would be returning to the Republican party leadership with her tail between her legs... and so she would be ceding a large measure of self-respect.

The external barriers are being supplied as we speak by the wingnut right, one of whom has suggested that those who disagree with Sen. Snowe's position send her bags of rock salt so that "Snowe can be melted away." On the one hand, this is typical juvenile antics. On the other hand, however, there is an undercurrent of malevolence here which cannot be ignored. While wishing someone dead is nowhere near as bad as taking steps to kill that person, sending a white powdery substance to a US Senator echoes the anthrax that was mailed to several Senators post 9/11. Juvenile antics can turn deadly, especially when unhinged minds hear the repeated message that those with whom you disagree politically are fair game for elimination from the planet.

If this sort of intimidation tactic were meant to get Sen. Snowe to abandon her position, I would venture a safe bet that this will only further harden her commitment to the course she has set. And now that her Maine colleague has suggested she is inclined to support health care (insurance) reform, Sen. Snowe's resolve is likely strengthened.

With the Maine moderate Republicans on board, the arguments of conservative Democrats, that there's not enough support for major reform, crumbles. They, too, are now on the hook for whatever comes out of the House and Senate. Indeed, the momentum has shifted dramatically that the final bill will include the public option. (That thing the MSM villagers have repeatedly told us is dead). After all, the three House committee versions and the Senate HELP committee version include it, so the pressure is on to move in that direction.

I, Uh, Well, Um
by Urquhart

just don't, uh, see, uh

That makes no sense whatsoever. Firstly, she's explicitly stated that she would not vote for a government plan. And B, there's no way that the CBO will score any bill that comes to the Senate floor as remotely deficit-neutral. Too many taxes in the Baucus bill, too many obligations in the liberal bill. They'll compromise on a budget-buster.

Also, the moderates so far have shown no signs of falling into line due to the highly touted Snowementum the WH was hoping to create.

And keep your mind off whatever's between Snowe's legs, please.

Re: In for a penny, in for a pound
by LaurieAnnM

Agree on the silliness of rednecks sending her rock salt in opposition to her voting with the democrats.

Good food for thought on how it will all play out for herself, politically and for the country as these bills proceed and evolve through this arduous process.Hopefully, we will get some shoring up of the points in Health Care that need shoring up.But, at the end of the day we will somehow with much good effort, on the part of the GOP and Indy opposition will retain our competitive edge in high quality care.

View as RSS news feed in XML