enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Completely and Totally Eroneous. A failure to journalism
by ambrosij

This article is one of the most erroneous and inaccuarate articles I have ever read. If you do not believe that the heat has indeed gotten over 150 then talk to some of your peers that have been to Iraq as reporters, surely they will tell you that during the dog days of summer 130 is a normalcy. In the military we use very high tech thermometers, and the reason for this is to gauge the heat index for our risk assessments, yes everything including the temperature is figured into operations. It is both a wet bulb and dry bulb reading, and it is very accurate. I have personnally seen the reading at 146, at around 4PM in the middle of August. And as for the comment about the type of heat....where are most operations being conducted? In Baghdad right? What surrounds Baghdad...a river right? Well the humidity generated by the river is stiffling I personally operated South of Baghdad near the river, where the foilage is closer to jungle than desert, and with the flooding of the fields and the humidity from the river, I would argue that at times the humidity was near 100%. And as for the weight soldiers carry, Senator McCain is incorrect. We do not carry 40 pounds, in fact the plates alone weigh over 40 pounds if the side plates are in. Once you add ammunition and a weapon the weight is closer to 60 pounds, add in a gallon of water and we are closer to 70. If you have any questions post to this and I will answer them, until then stop publishing information that is not true.

Re: Completely and Totally Eroneous. A failure to journalism
by leeanddonna
Actually he probably got his information from the White House and the Pentagon where everything is not true.
Re: Completely and Totally Eroneous. A failure to journalism
by sgreen
If I were like some others who have posted in the Fray on this topic, I would accuse you of being a treasonous leftist trying to undermine McCain and lose the war by pointing out that he was wrong on the weight the troops carry.
Breathe.
by Wolfen

The ENTER key is your friend.

I'm sorry that official statistics don't match your own experience. I'm sorry that the thermometers observed by all appeared to be quite cheap civilian brands, placed in improper conditions.

No one is disputing that it is miserable there. It's Hell. We get it.

But it's not 146 degrees. You'd be dead. Especially wearing all your 70 pounds of gear.

Re: Breathe.
by Crunchy One

The highest recorded temperature EVER was 136 F, at Al'Aziziyah, Libya, on September 13, 1922.

Nearly all thermometers will show a higher than ambient temperature when exposed to direct sunlight.

Uhhh, yeah. We know.
by Wolfen

That's what the article stated. I agreed with it.

Why dredge up this post from two months ago?

View as RSS news feed in XML