Re: Good Ole Fashioned....Morals...
by
nagatuki
08/04/2009, 5:25 PM #
gunsmoke:lets push that back a 100 years and we will find that Blacks, Indians, and women were "not people" either. If that is your ethical cornerstone- I imagine it will crumble as technology progresses to the point that we think of a fetuses as "real people."
Says who? Says the scientists that have shown, thus far, that literally the first few weeks of an embryo there is no evidence of functioning brain or nerves.
Look, your argument is like apples and oranges; the whole "not people" line wasn't based on any scientific logic; it was based on racism, sexism and any other 'ism you've got.
The scientific approach to embryos is entirely different, and as of now, they are not considered "persons" until they can function outside a womb on their own. And please, don't bog down the argument with "well, they really can't live on their own for many years, so soon you'll argue that children and babies should also have no rights and can be killed."
I've heard that slippery slope, too, and it's also stupid.