So how big will this list of "autonomic functions" become before you finally throw up the bullshit flag and protest?
##### Ive been throwing my arms up in disgust about our needless wars and bloated military budget for decades--there remains more waste in this area than any other and our budget is more than ten times greater than that of the next closest nation. Where is YOUR bullshit flag? What makes less sense financially? Individual group plans for every branch of government and for the medicare/medicaid program coupled with private insurance for everyone else and then only making the middle class pay for it OR OR OR one system we all share to keep the overall costs way down? The number two cause of bankruptcy in this nation is health care expenses....that should count for something.
" So....if the fed decided that along with social healthcare, comes individual responsibilities? To ensure we are all doing what we can to keep the costs of free healthcare down....the fed will mandate a physical training program that we all have to participate in order to keep our freebies? Surely you must agree that there are certain behaviors that carry more health risks than others right? No guarantees...but we do need to do our part to mitigate risk."
###### Actually I am glad you brought that up. Do you know how many of our health care costs are driven by untreated dug, cigarette, alcohol abuses as well as poor overall lifestyles? How often is the decision to avoid treatment based on personal costs? Sure, we could punish people (like we do today) and increase our costs or we could get them into treatment and reimburse people for health club memberships (as many insurance companies do today). No it wont be perfect and there will always be people who make poor lifestyle choices, but historically we have seen that a lot of things dont seem to affect mortality the way you think it should--marathon runners die before their fiftieth birthday sometimes while cigar smoking heavy drinkers live to their eighties--one thing is sure though--lack of treatment means more expenses later--and the big reason for lack of treatment is the exhorbinant out of pocket expenses to the patient--make someone choose between their home and medical treatment....THAT is a better way?
"So, further more....the fed will mandate that you wear items to protect your skull and joints when moving about on public thoroughfares outside of a vehicle. They will mandate a list of PPE (personal protective equipment) you must be wearing....or risk having to foot the bill yourself for any injuries sustained.
###### Actually there are already a wide range of mandatory safety requirements to drive and to operate a bike, skateboard, etc.Many states fought the seatbelt laws, many others didnt want to raise the drinking age to 21 either.....and this all went on well before Obama and we still dont have the associated free health care---your mandatory safety requirements have been working their way through the states under both dems and cons and no free health care driving it....INSURANCE companies appear to be driving it.
You can't play tackle football....or basketball in the rain. If there is lighting within five miles....you must stay indoors.
###### While I think you're sinking deep into paranoia here I would remind you that most pro and semi pro sports teams and even leauges for amateurs require you sign a waiver taking personal resoponsibility and declaring you wont be suing them. Again this isnt driven by free healthcare but rather by their insurance companies and legal pros.
You can't just not show up to work one day after calling in to take a sick day....you gotta bring a note from the doctor....before any time off is taken outside of a doctors visit. And by the way, we will check up on you....if you are supposed to be in bed sick...that is where you had better be. Not out getting a mani and pedi, or eating a big mac.
####### I dont know where you work Rubma but if you call in sick and are not sick where I work that is grounds for getting yourself fired. Employers can and do check up, some require notes, and playing hookie can indeed get you a ticket to the pavement.
Don't think this could happen? This is socialized healthcare in the military..... and it's buried in cost overruns and expenses too.
##### OK Rubma but keep in mind you NEVER lose that free care. Were you in the real world outside the military your idea of quality care would be gone as soon as a shareholder needed to make an extra nickel...lay off a couple more people and profits go up. And as I said what makes more sense, your private socialized care just for the military folks or you and us civilians sharing a single service?
You are so willing to save a buck that you will give up everything that has been brought to you by the blood of those gone long before us.....
##### You dont think the founders were trying to save a buck? You do remember the roll taxes played in the founding of this nation right? As to blood spilled, much of that was pissed away in needless wars--honor for the troops perhaps but their leaders deserve not a shred of honor for sending them to needless deaths. Dont throw the sacrifice chip around Rubma--it comes in many ways and not just in spilt blood--families, workers, and even the protestors who force the political chicken hawks to justify their actions all make sacrifices.
If the framers had intended to have welfare, food stamps, and social security....we would have had it over 200 years ago vice 70.
###### Well see Rubma things have changed a lot. I just cant go out and shoot dinner these days in most parts of the USA and thus my choice is work or starve...and since there is no guaranty of work what choices do I have? Back in the founders days I could have moved my family west and simply taken land, I could go out and shoot dinner--this is not the world we live in today though is it? While the cons can talk a good game about common defense, they like to ignore the other half of why a government exists--the "general welfare" means the shared resources we use to make our nation better for those who live here--and you wont gripe about police, fire deparments, DPW, health department, education, and a wide range of other things I pay for whether I want to or not but man do you guys get steamed about health care or taking care of the poor (a very Christian notion btw according to some guy named Jesus).
At this rate...we won't be able to vote shit out of office or take up arms against it. Take a look at the 21st ammendment for evidence of this....the fed simply holds funds from the states until the state does what the fed desires...or the state doesn't get its share that year.
###### Well that is the deal isnt it? We get equal representation in the senate and the idea is that the states have a say in the federal law making. If your state doesnt like it but the majority does, welcome to democracy. Of course a state like Maine might not see a need for gun control and might believe the laws dont make sense-while in NYC and LA and Chicago, the weekly murder rate drives a different point of view.....we have the ability to give states a lot of latitude but not always....restricting gun sales in NYC just means someone makes a road trip to Maine. So yes, the federal government can and will make decisions which make less sense in some states than others...but we agree as members to accept laws made for the majority and dont try to rule for the exceptions except when it violates the rights we agree to as citizens.
I reference the 21st ammendment only because it explicitly places laws regarding alcohol in the laps of the states....and one by one, as they became more and more dependent on fed funds....each state became like the other.
##### You could of course refuse those funds though. And keep in mind that you certainly wouldnt want states ignoring the fed when your personal pet issues arise. What would happen if the NE states could insist that the taxes we pay only be used here instead of paying for the massive welfare requirements of the con states in the rust belt and the agricultural centers? What if liberal states wouldnt agree to the draft in a con war of choice? Sure, you can fight for the right to an 18 year old drinking age but at what cost?
It will be no different when we become subservient to our government due to ever increasing dependence on it.
##### Dependence on it? I dont depend on our military to go out and attack people who never attacked us at all yet I am expected to pay for it am I not? You ask that we all work yet no assurance of a job, you demand we pay for our own health care yet dont provide us health care anyone can afford realistically. Your idea of a conservative utopia absolves the government of a role supporting its citizens for what they pay in taxes yet supports a military mission of aggression which lines up conveniently with the goals of corporate America but not its employees. If I take away the free college, the free healthcare, and the free housing will the military still be attractive to you? How about we start cost cutting by making the GI pay for his own food, shelter, and health care like we do to citizens?
And our European friends....lived under kings and tyrants, and have evolved towards democracy with a flair for socialism...something still a part of their long pasts of serfdom and slavery.
###### You think this is the case? Maybe they saw how health care and general basics of life were pathetic under the serf system and they believed the high taxes they pay should actually have a measurable return on their investment in their nation. I know many Canadians and they are aware they pay higher taxes but they also know if they lose their job they will have reasonable care--they also have robust private industry. Socialism is how you can describe any form of government at all--if we dont use our collective money, skills, and support then what benefit is there to government at all? Why not just have law of the jungle?
Perhaps, if we give them long enough....they will find our way better.
##### I doubt that. As it is they point to us an example of capitalism gone out of control and they see our military as thinly veiled imperialism. They back up these comments with pretty solid evidence too.
Hell...it worked for us rather quickly....and worked much better than social democracy ever did for Germany.
###### You might want to talk to a typical German before you say that. Sure, they regret what the Nazis became, but they also know that before Hitler they were mired in a depression worse than our own. And ask if they would sacrifice their health care to have their own military again and I doubt you will find any takers.