enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Page 1 of 2 (25 items)   1 2 Next >
Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by Vermin8
+9 Reply

An 17-18 yo girl who realizes prom is not important is showing maturity.

A middle aged woman who is wistful over missing prom is sad.

That's right!
by tonto_goldberg
Still, there's a whole bunch of magazines hoping that "Your Prom" is truly a life-or-death matter. There are dresses to be sold, tuxedos and limos to be rented, acne cream and hair products to be slathered about, legs (and more) to be shaved or waxed, shoes to hurt young women's feet, and who knows what else at stake.
Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by Tarquin Machismo
At least the prom gives some teenage girls a chance to be a princess for a day so they don't start obsessing about the perfect wedding.
Re: That's right!
by hikari

tonto_goldberg:
Still, there's a whole bunch of magazines hoping that "Your Prom" is truly a life-or-death matter. There are dresses to be sold, tuxedos and limos to be rented, acne cream and hair products to be slathered about, legs (and more) to be shaved or waxed, shoes to hurt young women's feet, and who knows what else at stake.

In that sense, prom is a rehearsal for one's eventual wedding, ergo, we gotta nab 'em early and drill home the importance of overpaying for attire, flowers, food and entertainment. Some prom girls even wear tiaras. Because as everyone knows, a young girl's mission in life has to be to look like a princess, so she can snag a man. One can never start too early with princess-like behavior. Indeed, if one waits until 18 years old to begin, it may already be too late!

Maybe more kids these days have adopted LW's attitude towards prom . .ie, it doesn't really beat an evening spent with Facebook or eating pizza with friends. While I deride the increasing casualness of our society in general, I think this is a more realistic attitude. Prom is an artificially adult occasion foisted on an age group that really isn't accustomed to getting all dressed up and making small talk over punch all night. 16-18 year olds are pressured to assume behaviors on that night that are more in the realm of the 20-somethings . . .mostly all on their parents' dime. The concept of prom is all very Fitzgerald . . .but do kids really want that stuff anymore?

When I was in high school in the 1980s, at my huge, middle-class school, prom was a huge fat, hairy deal. The hugest. It was practically a suicide-worthy offense not to get invited to prom. The irony was that our prom was held in our high school cafeteria. So people dropped a few hundred bucks, minimum, to get all gussied up to dance in the place where they ate lunch every day. The place still reeked of mashed potatoes and overcooked vegetables, and the cheesy handpainted decorations by the junior class didn't do a thing to disguise the smell. Big whoop. It was hardly a "Pretty in Pink" scenario at a ritzy big-city hotel. Hardly! But the entire worth of your high school experience was somehow predicated on whether you got asked to this cheesy dance and therefore had the opportunity to wheedle your mom into spending a pile on a dress and your hair appointment. Or, if you had a part-time job, practically all your yearly earnings went toward prom expenditures. You were practically deemed a social leper if you didn't go. All to party in the cafeteria. Like LW, I saw very little point in attending prom, when I could go to an amusement park for the day with half the money and 20 times the fun quotient.

Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by rndrc
I could not agree with you more-I was never interested in Proms, and ended up going to my senior prom basically because my older sister, and my boyfriend's older sister did the prudie thing and we went more or less to keep the peace. But our instincts were right-we did try, but just were not that into it, left early, went home got pizza watched an old horror movie and had a blast. Telling someone that one day, in the misty future, you will be sorry for not going to the Prom is akin to the bride wailing that it's "The Happiest Day of Her Life"-One surely hopes that there is more to life than either of these days; ultimately it is up to the teen to decide-she may go and love it, or hate it; she may opt out and regret it or not; but scaring her into going is teaching her not to follow her "gut" and make her feel like somehow her feelings about this issue are wrong-She knows what's right for her
Re: That's right!
by Hemlock3630

My Junior and Senior years prom weren't in the highschool at all (early 90's). All through the year the student government did fundraisers for the prom so that we could have our prom somewhere other than the gym. Prom my Junior year was held at a fancy hotel, and Senior prom was held at the Civic Center (they raised alot of money that year...). Same thing with the after graduation party. We had live bands, no DJ.

It wasn't all about getting dressed up and being a princess, (at least for me and my friends) it was a night to go out and pretend at being grown-up, and be more formal than we were ever used to being. And just hand out and have fun with our group. Yes, one in our group put a lot of emotion riding on the prom, and "Oh! This is the man I'm going to marry (she's messed up in the head anyway...)" and went and got a hotel and missed most of prom. the rest of us thought she was an idoit. Have some good memories, and funny stories (like my Junior prom date who parked in front of a 'No Parking, Violators Will Be Towed' sign.....I mentioned the sign and he said it would be fine....oh well, the car was towed :) and it was funny watching him run around "Where's my car!!!")

I do think Prudie's right, that people (especially girls) who stress about Prom are those same ones who are going to freak about weddings......run away from those women as fast as possible!

Re: That's right!
by rndrc

Hikari

"The concept of prom is all very Fitzgerald . . ." What a completely accurate and amazing sentence-I love it!

Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by cat51
I totally agree. I didn't go to prom, decades ago (not saying how many!) and I never gave it another thought. The only time it came up at all was when my daughter wanted to go, and I felt a little bad that I couldn't tell her how it would be/should be... but I realized that whatever happened back in the dark ages when I was in high school would have little relevance to her either, and everything worked out great and she had a wonderful time. She wanted to go, I never did. Whatever, people are different.
Re: That's right!
by bluegriphon

I've gotta side against Prudie on this - although I understand her standpoint, as I was ornery as a teenager and prone to bouts of contrariness for the sake of contrariness. I took her tack, even as an 18-year-old, thinking I would regret not going when I was older, even though I was completely indifferent to the whole ordeal and even skipped several Homecomings. I engaged in the rituals, found a diverse crowd of single folks to go stag with, and donned the cummerbund and carnation, and headed to the hotel.

I was bored out of my gourd, spent 30 minutes watching the ice sculptures slowly melt, along with my patience, and then jetted, along with my friends, picking up some Boone's Strawberry Hill on the way out to the country, laying some blankets out in a field, and watching the stars arc through the Texas sky while talking until dawn.

If anything, I might suggest, for those individuals not inclined to enjoy this kind of forced mating ritual (sorry, had to get that dig in), to gather other like-minded kids and throw an anti-prom - not in a vicious or gloomy way, but simply in a way that is in alignment with one's personality.

Re: That's right!
by hikari
rndrc:

Hikari

"The concept of prom is all very Fitzgerald . . ." What a completely accurate and amazing sentence-I love it!

Thank you. :) I knew my American literature degree would come in handy some day.

Re: That's right!
by hikari

P.S. . . .not that I don't have my moments of wishing our contemporary culture could return to that past elegance. But then I remember that the Roaring 20s were followed by the Big Crash.

Hey, wait a minute--we had the Big Crash, but it's not like the 'Oughts' have been very Jazz-Age, have they? I think we've gotten gypped!

Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by hikari

Tarquin Machismo:
At least the prom gives some teenage girls a chance to be a princess for a day so they don't start obsessing about the perfect wedding.

But, au contraire . . .in my opinion that's where the obsessing about the perfect wedding usually begins, no? It's all the rage now to throw gigantic Sweet 16 parties that rival a prom/wedding reception. In the area where I grew up, there's a big Greek community and they throw graduation parties for their girls that are very like a junior wedding reception in tone . . .except that everyone's stag and most have acne. So a parent could ostensibly swing for a graduation party, two proms (junior and senior) and a graduation shindig within a two-year period. I tend to find that among girls, all these princess-for-a-day occasions just feed the beast! A Sweet 16/Junior Prom Miss-zilla just breeds a larger and nastier Bridezilla, eventually.

Of course, this depends on the family values of each girl. If she is expected to pay for all or some of her prom costs by getting a job or using her babysitting money, and if she must choose between a Sweet 16 bash OR a graduation party, incipient 'zilla' tendencies might be nipped in the bud by sensible parents. But if the parents lavish her with prom and birthday stuff (and let her watch TLC) they might be nurturing a baby Bridezilla. If so, they have only themselves to blame.

Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by Skelli

I never attended a high-school dance, and I've never regretted it. Spent anti-prom with two guys playing miniature golf (I got my ass kicked).

Have to agree with Hikari that more 'perfect day' opportunities just feed the bridezilla complex. If only they'd learn that you can dress up on your own terms whenever you want to, but people only have to pay attention to you whenever *they* want to.

My girlfriends and I never missed out on the fancy-dress part. We skipped all those highschool dances, but once every few years we'd buy tickets to a musical or something, dress to the nines, and take ourselves out. Much classier and more entertaining, thanks.

Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by bagelwoman
Seriously! I've never once looked back and wished I'd had "the prom experience." Gak! I still think it's as ridiculous and unappealing as I did 20 years ago. Prudie's advice was just sad.
Re: Suggestion: PromQueen should give Prudie Advice
by Jessica666
I did not go to the prom and I am still very pleased with my choice all these years later. "The prom," who cares.
Page 1 of 2 (25 items)   1 2 Next >
View as RSS news feed in XML