Shoddy Science Reporting Complicit in Anti-Intellectualism
by
rjgwood
11/18/2008, 11:37 PM #
Because of the sensationalism committed by science reporters, American's mistrust of science has been amplified. Without bothering to explain the process of science, and the need for replications of studies, and without stressing all the follow-up work required to verify a scientific position or statement, science reporters and the news outlets that run them, have screaming headlines that inform American's of the latest danger or shocking story, only to have a story run counter to it shortly thereafter. A prime example has been reporting on caffine. Headlines blared the news about the danger of caffine causing cancer, then other ailiments, some touted beneficence, and then it was benign. The American public watches these headlines, and their confidence in science is eroded. They blame the scientists, and believe that theories are nothing more than guesses.
Of course, the majority of blame for the lack of knowledge about science rests with the disinterested American education system. But, science reporting has contributed to this lack of trust in the scientific process. A case in point is the belief that creationism is just as valid a "theory" as evolution. And look at how conservatives are able to use this doubt in science to devalue the work done on climate change and global warming.
As the mother of a child with autism, I can attest to the erratic nature of science reporting, and to the confusion and distrust that it causes. Each week I learn of a new "cause" of autism by another reporter angling to be the writer with the "hot" story. The reporting is usually nothing more than a glorified press release, and usually does little to explain the true nature of the scientific investigations and revelations that are produced in the field.
Science reporters need to start taking responsibility for their role in this process by working to undo some of their damage by educating the American public about the behind the scenes processes of science - and make it just as sexy, so people will read it!