enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Kol Nidre and Reform Jews
by BarkinJ

The author of the article suggests that Reform Jews don't say Kol Nidre (or don't hear it recited in their synagogues):

A rabbinical conference in Brunswick in 1844 ruled unanimously that Kol Nidre was superfluous and should be eliminated from the entire religious tradition. This decision led numerous congregations in Western Europe and many more Reform congregations in the United States to do just that, or to replace the words of the prayer with a Hebrew psalm while retaining its elegaic melody. Orthodox and Conservative congregations still recite the words.

The suggestion is false. Though the description of the incident in question is historically accurate (and some Western European and American Reform congregations abandoned Kol Nidre), on Erev Yom Kippur you can hear Kol Nidre being sung in virtually every Reform congregation in the world.

Reform Jews have every reason to give up the prayer, since it largely deals with the halakhic (Jewish legal) system of vows. One tenet of Reform Judaism is a distancing from that legal tradition. The problem is that Kol Nidre is so important to Jewish culture and psyche that it cannot be removed, even if its actual meaning is ideologically inconsistant with what most people in the pews actually believe.

Re: Kol Nidre and Reform Jews
by fsilber
It's conceivable that even if German Jews removed it from the Reform liturgy, it may have been restored in many Temples and new members of Eastern European ancestry wanted it back for sentimental reasons.
View as RSS news feed in XML