No, in this case, the court clearly showed that there were questionable registration forms submitted by poorly trained and over zealous ACORN volunteers.
That formed the basis of the settlement.
The part about the names used is probably false. This is Michelle Maklin after all! You can't take any of this at face value.
Her assertions about massive voter fraud in 17 other states is false. There is no record of any litigation or FEC action in 17 states, only the loud and baseless acusations by right wing bloggers.
IT's ironic that Malkin specifically mentions Missouri.
The case she is talking about there was filed by the US Attorney in the Western District (Kansas City), only days before the November elections.
The ink was barely dry in the court filings when every right wing radio talking and Fox Noise started screaming about ACORN and how the Justice Department was going after them.
Remember this was less than a week before the election.
The rest of the story is interesting as well.
IT seem that the US Attorney in the Western District of Missouri had been on the job for less than six months. He replaced a former Bush apointee who had been summarily fired for no cause.
The new US Attorney had very little if any prosecutorial experience, but was a former staffer of Karl Rove.
His name is Barry Schlotzman.
Less than two weeks after the November election, Schlotzman's suit against ACORN was dismissed summarily.
The following year, the House Government Reform Committee began looking into the rash of US Attorney firings that had occcurred between 2004 and 2006.
As with many of the sneekier aspects of the Bush adminstration, these firings violated longstanding tradition. Presidential appointees ususally serve the length of the adminstration unless they retire, get appointed to something else, or have some ethical or performance problem.
In a little noticed manuever, the Bush adminstration inserted a provision into the renewal of the USA Patriot Act that removed the 90 day time limit in the terms of interim presidential appointements, meaning that these new appointees didn't have to be confirmed by the Senate.
This was how Rove's lieutenant became US Attorney in Missouri,
He immediately began a caging operation to eliminate "unqualified" voters and purge the rolls of Democratic voters.
This was a time honored GOP practice. KAtherine Harris had run a huge voter caging operation in Florida in 2000. and the GOP ran caging operations in Missouri, Ohio, and New Mexico in 2006. They had started one in Michigan this year, but they got caught early on.
The next task in the startegy was the nuisance suit against ACORN.
Justice Department guidelines state that legal actions of this sort should not be filed in the 90 days before an election, lest they appear to be politically motivated.
Schlotzman reluctantly admitted that he knew of this policy and willfully violated it in bringing the ACORN suit. He aslo defied the credibility of the committee by claiming not to know what a voter caging operation was, even though it was clear that he was running a caging operation.
The next day he resigned.
One week later, Rove resigned.
This is what we're really talking about here.
The only weapon the GOP has this year is its propoganda machine.
So, they gin up all the old stories, knowing that sheep like Terrortoon won't connect the dots or fact check anything.
Fortuneately, this year, it seems to only be working for the true believers.