enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Reason for weight gain
by SlateSurfer
+1/-1 Reply

I think Prudie was a bit too flippant on this one. Did she not notice that the weight gain coincided with the year the LW has been living with her boyfriend? Isn't it possible there's some connection there? Either a lifestyle change (maybe their eating habits together or their exercise habits)...or maybe the boyfriend is passive agressive causing the LW anxiety and depression making her eat more. Cuz not having sex with your gf instead of coming straight out and telling her what's going on for you strikes me as a sign of an unhealthy relationship.

I agree that going from a 16 to a 20 in one year is cause for alarm, but such rapid weight gain might signify that more than Weight Watcher's is warranted.

Re: Reason for weight gain
by zbird

"Cuz not having sex with your gf instead of coming straight out and telling her what's going on for you strikes me as a sign of an unhealthy relationship."

I don't know--telling your gf that she's fat is a good way to end a healthy relationship, along with your life. And there aren't really any nice ways of saying it.

Also, I agree that 16 -->20 is pretty dramatic and merits professional attention, but I think Prudie's point was just that the LW shouldn't take her weight as given and treat the relationship as something to be repaired, when in fact the opposite might be true.

Also, as for relationship dyanmics surrounding the weight gain--you could be right about but it could be the LW was no longer on the prowl and therefore just let herself go.
Re: Reason for weight gain
by Devin T
Prudie was right, and blaming one's weight gain on anxiety and depression caused by a bf is what so many significant others do to avoid the simple fact that weight gain is most commonly caused by too much food, not enough exercise (and a mountain of self pity). The Oprah crowd loves to vilify the bf in this situation, but the bf can both love her and yet not be physically attractive. However, he can express his love by offering to go running with her, cook healthy meals together, etc.
correction
by Devin T
that should be '..and not be physically attracted to her.'
Re: correction
by RHWH

There are all sorts of reasons for weight gain, and "settling down" is a major risk factor for some of us. Your lifestyle simply changes - when you eat, what you eat, what time you get for excercise (or other personal pursuits) changes. Maybe men are better at not allowing co-habitation change these habits than women are, but women, as a rule, adapt to the man. I gained a bit of weight when I first got married because I was cooking for him and eating the way he ate.

People are way to glib about the idea that all you have to do is excersise more and eat less. People have different set points, and this woman's is kind of high, evidentally. Read "Rethinking Thin" for the science on the subject - doctors and scientists have known the same thing for ages: what you're meant to be, you're meant to be. You can fight it for awhile, but unless you want to fight every minute of your life, you're going to be what you're going to be. And fighting is exhausting. It doesn't leave time for the rest of life.

However, this young woman shouldn't be so glib about a large weight gain in a short period. She shouldn't be so unconcerned - she'd be better off finding out what's going on and losing it - if practicable - while she's young and energetic and before she begins to suffer health related problems from it. Also, I think people do have a responsibility to their mates to make an effort - you try to keep yourself well-groomed and attractive. You brush your teeth. You bathe. But partners also have to understand that physical changes do happen, and weight isn't entirely in one's own control. That's got nothing to do with Oprah, that's the way of the world. People used to understand and accept that, but now media has convinced us all that we're supposed to be the same.

Re: correction
by bpeck

Set points work both ways. If you have been at a certain weight for a while it takes effort to move to another weight and stay there. Once you have stayed there for a while your body becomes used to it and you have another set point. Some people have trouble gaining weight and have to work to eat enough. In most cases the gaining is easier.

Our bodies change as we grow older so maybe her lifestyle hasn't changed. Her metabolism could be slowing down so her body might be gravitating to a new set point. Most people in this situation chose to go along for the ride because it is the easy path. Others take the road less traveled and start watching what they eat and exercising more intelligently. Either way it is a choice.

Re: correction
by FirstInLastOut

what you're meant to be, you're meant to be. You can fight it for awhile, but unless you want to fight every minute of your life, you're going to be what you're going to be. And fighting is exhausting. It doesn't leave time for the rest of life.

Umm... what?

What do you mean by "fight it?" So by fight it you mean, its a fight to eat a salad instead of a cookie? Yeah, what a fight that is. You know, it's tough having energy all day, not feeling like crap, not needing to pee every 10 minutes from your body trying to expell all the sugar from the junk food you consumed.

I guess "fighting it" to you means actually eating what your body needs for health and actually exercising which will both make you feel better and happier, but also reset your metabolism as well. To me that's not "fighting it," thats living life the way it was meant to be lived.

Re: correction
by jcruz

I wish someone other than me had given my wife the same advice Prudence gave to this young woman. My wife started packing on the pounds from the time we got engaged. Unlike most women who try to lose weight for the wedding, she actually gained so much she had to have the dress resized. After the wedding the weigh gain continued. When I confronted her about it (as gently as I could) I got the tears, anger and silent treatment too. I do love her and just gave in an accepted it. Now she weighs 270 pounds.

Good for you Prudence for telling it like it is.

View as RSS news feed in XML