The sign of a First Rate Mind
by
degsme
09/01/2008, 3:25 PM #
When Fitzgerald wrote:
The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time
He was being sarcastic. The notion that you can be "pro-life" and somehow pro death penalty is about as oxymoronic as it gets. Sure you can redefine "life" to be restricted to only "the innocent", and you can further NewSpeak it to exclude those who must be punished, but you are twisting the meaning of language past the point even Orwell would have recognized.
Either you are Pro-Life - ie against the taking of life - or you are not. If you are not, then you allow rationalizations for the taking of other human life. And as GB Shaw wrote - at that point you're just haggling over the price,
OR
You reserve the right FOR YOURSELF to judge /Choose which life is "innocent" and which deserves to be "put down"
Now you can rationalize all you want, but those are your two positions. Which means that if you are pro Death Penalty, then you cannot be "pro-life". You can only assert that you want the choice for yourself as to who lives and who dies.
And that means that you are being dishonest in describing yourself as "pro-life".
As for Roe. Let me ask you this:
I assume you consider that carrying a fetus to term is a valuable thing for a woman to do. That in doing so she provides the fetus with the opportunity to gestate and grow, and she helps society's moral standing. Am I on track?