Re: All it takes are slogans and backers?
by
REALITY CALLS
08/29/2008, 12:54 PM #
I appreciate your Robin Hood thinking. The costume is a riot, too.
Here's an analogy for you: in real estate, the owner of a condo owns their actual apartment. There is a governing board for the building, but true ownership exists and apartments can be bought-and-sold. Alternatively, the owner of a co-op might own a share of their building, but not the actual apartment they live-in. It is merely the apartment the governing board permits them to occupy. Their share of the building, if sold, might go back to the governing board without turning a profit.
The difference between the two different governing boards is the difference between two societies. In the first, you work, you save, you negotiate, you buy, you manage within the rules of an agreement, you sell and hopefully realize a gain on your investment. In the second, you work, you save, you buy, you are given instructions, you sell and hopefully get your savings out.
Apply these standards to the entire economy and you have the difference between your philosophy and mine: citizens versus subjects. There are a lot of people who refuse to work their whole lives and be given orders by a Counsel of Wise Men, especially when folk like yourself will chose them. Moreover, if you want to expand the social safety net (and you will) to include more-and-more services, these must be taken in taxes from people who would have spent their own money differently, and from government appropriations in other areas. It’s the old guns-versus-butter argument: a nation can’t have a military and a consumer sector, which is why the Soviet Union had a military and shortages of everything else. You want a social safety net, and you can't afford a military.
As this nation is at war, you need to do one or more of the following: (1) consider our enemies beaten (2) consider our enemies overrated (3) consider our allies not worth the effort (4) consider America the enemy.
You know which of these already inform your thinking.