Re: Go ahead, screw up with your platform
by
kaiso
08/19/2008, 9:19 AM #
"You know, it's not like I'm the only one that feels this way."
I didn't say that. I said it was highly arguable, which it certainly is. The fact that - as you acknowledge - somewhere between 20% to 80% of people do NOT agree that a fetus is definitely as much a "person" as its mother - should tell you that.
"And I'd like to see your scientific evidence that a developing human embryo is somehow NOT alive and NOT human."
When did I say that? You do, however, acknowledge that it is a developing human embryo. I assume you know the scientific evidence for that - that an embryo is not the same thing as an infant; that there are many, many stages of development that an embryo passes through in a continuum, and that the capabilities of embryos destroyed in early abortions amount to primitive circulation, and that's about it.
"You are also being overly emotional, assuming I want to ban abortion because I disagree with the author."
I may be incorrect, but I'm not being overly emotional, as you are in stating as if it's an unarguable fact that "an innocent person always dies during an abortion", as if fully viable and born infants are being lined up and shot, instead of the truth, which is that human embryos in the early stages of development are being destroyed.
If by stating that, you are not stating that you believe I should not be allowed to decide for myself the fate of my "innocent person"/developing embryo, then I'm not sure WHAT you are saying. Are you saying that I should be allowed to kill innocent people for my own convenience? Because you certainly don't seem to be saying that "personhood" is not clearly defined here and that I should be allowed to make my own decision, and I don't see what an alternative stance to those two would be.