Re: Christopher Merola lied!
by
fingerpuppet
07/12/2008, 1:23 PM #
Again we have fresh evidence that the pro-war side continues to intentionally disseminate carefully worded misleading information. A careful perusal of the AP story shows that nowhere do they assert that the uranium ore in question related to Saddam's alleged attempt to acquire uranium ore from Niger since the first gulf war. In fact, even the most intellectually dishonest neocons never tried to claim that Saddam had actually succeeded in those alleged efforts, only that he had supposedly proposed a deal. And even those allegations are known to be dubious at best.
The uranium ore that was just removed from Iraq was the same stockpile that the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) had known about from its inspections immediately after the first gulf war. It was most likely acquired during the 1980s, and had been sealed and unavailable to Saddam since the early 1990s. It has absolutely nothing to do with Joe Wilson and Valerie Plame. These facts are not new, but they're being presented in a misleading way to allow the credululous, unsophisticated or willfully ignorant -- people like you, apparently -- to misconstrue the situation.
The Iraq Survey Group's final report in 2004 stated the following:
In May 2003, coalition forces visited the former yellowcake extraction plant at Al-Qaim and discovered 16 drums of yellowcake and radioactive waste—materials we believe were associated with the pre-1991 nuclear weapons program. These drums were transferred in late June 2003 to the yellowcake storage facility located at Tuwaitha. There is no evidence that this material had been produced after Desert Storm
[ ... ]
During the 1970s and early 1980s, Iraq bought uranium in various forms from the international market. These materials included about 486 tons of yellowcake, 33,470 kg of “natural” uranium dioxide, 1,767 kg of “low-enriched” uranium dioxide (2.6 percent 235U), and 6,005 kg of “depleted” uranium dioxide from Portugal, Italy, Niger, and Brazil.
Iraq also had domestic sources for uranium ore.
So please, explain to us in more detail how this proves Joe Wilson wrong. Explain to us how this uranium ore, that is known to have been sealed away for more than 15 years, has anything at all to do with Joe Wilson or the alleged attempt to acquire uranium from Niger since the first gulf war. Go ahead, we're waiting . . .