Wow, deja vu re: Rebecca Walker! (I like her writing, and everyone else seems to feel she is a hack)
I have always loved Maureen Downd's columns. I find her to be bright, funny, observant, and insightful. Yes, she usually uses sarcasm and hyperbole as her method, but I do kinda like that contrarian approach. To me, she is a strong, smart woman who does what she wants, and I like that. I am disappointed then her column does appear in the Times, and am always excited when I see she has column that day.
But then I almost always see things differently from most everyone else in any context, so I may be wrong...
Carolle