Go to Ask.com


enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Dear Crabby - "ducked soup" edition
by baltimore aureole
+13 Reply

Dear Crabby,

My elderly husband just died, and a friend wrote to confess she’d had an affair with him 25 years ago. I had suspected as much but kept it to myself, and haven’t replied to her yet. Part of me wants to forgive (like she wants) but let her know how hurt I am and never speak to her again, and part wants to just ignore her. What should I do?

— “The Mean Mile”

Dear “The Mate Tricks”,

My condolences on your loss. That said, you can’t forgive someone, then refuse to ever speak to them again. It doesn’t work like that. My own question, to help you sort this out: if you make her feel bad, then want to retract your snub at a later date, will you end up wanting to ask HER for forgiveness at some point? Also, how much heartache do you want to take into the sunset of your life? Do you not have enough already, that you need to make more?

— Crabby, who reminds all her readers that speaking ill of the departed is the depth of bad manners. They can’t defend themselves, or point out your lies and exaggerations, you know.

Dear Crabby,

I am about to be married to a great guy with disgusting table manners. We’ve known each other since we were 4 years old, and his manners haven’t changed since then. (Disgusting dining details redacted at this point – Crabby). How can I force him to eat daintily?

— “The Corn Ultimatum”

Dear “Ducked Soup”,

I’m sure if you just tell him “that’s gross, and the internet lady says to stop it” - THAT will have the desired effect, eh? Honestly, I don’t know why people think some anonymous internet know-it-all like me can force their loved (and unloved) ones to obey them. One of 2 things is happening here – either he’s totally clueless that he’s gross, and amenable to tactful advice, or he’s well aware of his effect, and chooses to be this way deliberately. There is hope for the former (and you don’t need to slip him a book – just talk to him like the dearest companion you purport to be, for pete’s sake). But there’s no hope if he’s doing this deliberately -you’ll have to decide if you want to be married to some guy who thinks this sort of thing is humorous, or not. Good luck, and please remember boys and girls that the dinner table is not a time for arguments.

— Crabby, who knows a woman who insists on cutting corn off the cob with a knife and fork, because eating it off the cob is “indelicate”. Seriously.

Dear Crabby,

I hate my mom because she physically and verbally abused me until I was 17. I am now 29 and about to give birth to my first child. Many of my friends and relatives are pressuring me to form a bond with her. How do I tell them to butt out?

— “Mommy Queerest”

Dear “Rosemary’s Baby’s Daughter”,

What to say to your “friends” who suggest you forgive and forget? I’d go with something like “That’s easy for you to say – YOUR mom didn’t lock you in a closet for hours, then beat you with a wire coat hanger.” Seriously, you don’t owe an explanation – or even an answer – to anyone. People will drop a topic if you refuse to be drawn into a debate over it. Half of them are simply bringing it up because they enjoy your obvious discomfort. These people are NOT your friends, and were put up to it by your mother. And don’t break down and renew your acquaintance with her just because you’re desperate later on for some free babysitting – that’s especially the time to remember how hellish life was for you, growing up. Think of the children, always.

—Crabby, who reconciles this “hold a grudge” advice with the “forgive” advice in letter one by noting that this granny to be apparently presents an imminent threat to the newborn’s well being.

Dear Crabby,

I’m an impoverished college student, and my relatives are bestowing gift cards to help me out. Unfortunately, I despise all the companies involved because they are opressve capitalist overlords who are exploiting the proletariat. How can I impose my socialist and revolutionary views on my relatives, but not lose the gifts? I simply want them to give me gifts from manufacturers and retailers which I personally approve of.

— “The Manchurian Matriculate”

Dear “Little Miss Cloudburst”,

I applaud your concern for the well being of those less fortunate than you. Unfortunately, your professors have omitted the part of “socialist economics 101” where it is revealed that refusing to purchase merchandise from 3rd world nations simply results in increased unemployment, hunger, and misery for proletariat who are then thrown out of work as a result. Some of them will then enter madrassas to fill their spare time, and become suicide bombers. Do you want this on your conscience? I didn’t think so! Accept the gift cards cheerfully, spend the amount you really need, and donate any excess to organizations which help the poor.

— Crabby, who believes you should have been able to figure out the solution for yourself. Consider inquiring about a tuition refund, since you’re not learning anything in college evidently.

Re: Dear Crabby - "ducked soup" edition
by xtine

I disagree that the man with bad table manners must be either clueless and amenable to advice, or deliberately offensive. There are more options than those two.

I am married to the most wonderful man in the world (seriously) and he has horrible table manners. He has never spit on a communal dish, but he does stuff his mouth full with one cheek bulging, and then talks with his mouth full and gulps down quantities of water or beer on top of all the food. He also holds his fork with his fist, licks his knife and other unsavory practices. He is not consistently outrageous, but he went into a seminary when he was fourteen and apparently they didn't teach them table manners, his siblings seem to be alright. I have talked to him about it and he does get defensive or laughs and asks me who makes these judgments about how people eat. He thinks I am unduly fastidious. He is a professor (and since he has a PhD and I do not, he is not in the habit of taking advice from me) and with tenure, I don't think it ever impacted his career, but you never know about those things. He did not object to my instructions to the kids to eat politely and since I only notice his manners occasionally, I can't be really objective about it. I just do not beleive that he is doing it on purpose to annoy me, or that his lack of interest in it is in anyway hostile. He really is the typical absent minded professor, and I think that is the real explanation. Not worth fighting about.

HAHAHA
by Rain

— Crabby, who believes you should have been able to figure out the solution for yourself. Consider inquiring about a tuition refund, since you’re not learning anything in college evidently.

Re: Dear Crabby - "ducked soup" edition
by magicienne

"Honestly, I don’t know why people think some anonymous internet know-it-all like me can force their loved (and unloved) ones to obey them."

I don't think she is going to go home and say "honey the internet lady thinks you are disgusting" I think people write to the advice columnests hoping for a secret manipulation technique. I'm sure most people who write those kind of letters are women and if you ever read a Cosmopolitan or other magaizine like that it is filled with articles teaching you "Don't say this.... say that to get what you want."

I had to stop reading those magazines since I was finding them ridiculous and a waste of money but a good one I did learn is if you know your SO loves to go bowling, and you don't want to go bowling. You don't ask what do you want to do tonight, you ask Do you want to go to the movies or to minigolf tonight. He picks one, doesn't realize he has a choice of bowling and you are happy too.

I think that is what people look for when they write those kind of letters... so the translation is "Oh wise woman, teach me your manipulation techniques so I can say one thing and he realizes the error of his ways."

Re: Dear Crabby - "ducked soup" edition
by IncogNeato

Here's a technique: Zen yoga, or something like it. Step into her private little Nirvana, and she can forget he even exists. Especially when some suave, smooth talkin' guy comes around, who knows how to eat in public, and who ignites that little spark she seems to be missing in this relationship!

She wants out, but isn't ready to admit it. He may also, which may be why he does his little passive aggressive looky-looky style eating, when he knows it bothers her. Or at least, they are both having second thoughts which they need to deal with before the wedding.

"he's a professor"
by baltimore aureole

wow . .. i was just going to ask that, then you outed him yourself.

um . .. always bad to make generalizations, which is why i always do it, so here goes.

"you cannot tell professors (or rich guys, or senators) anything. these guys all think they've won some sort of genius award, by virtue of the advanced degree, conning other people out of their money, or winning the popularity contest. i know this because i've had "relations" with all 3, believe it or not."

and another thing - you can't tell me anything either, since i'm genius after sleeping with those losers. their genius rubbed off on me, even as it rubbed me the wrong way.

thanks for your post and have a nice weekend.

crabby on "secret manipulation techniques"
by baltimore aureole
i know a bunch of these, but they're not fit to publish in a general interst publication like slate.
How I deal with snobby professors.
by IncogNeato
I simply remind them that I make about 25-30% more with my AAS than the average professor in this country.
Re: How I deal with snobby professors.
by Fitzpatrick

Nothing beats a hard-working ASS when it comes to making money.

Oh, wait...

Re: crabby on "secret manipulation techniques"
by Fitzpatrick

baltimore aureole:
i know a bunch of these, but they're not fit to publish in a general interst publication like slate.

Such a tease.

But maybe that's one of the techniques? I guess we'll never know.

top 10 things to say to professors
by baltimore aureole

to annoy them

10 - "it must be a real thrill meeting 500 new teenagers each fall who don't know a damn thing"

9 - "is there a way to tell when a student is really hitting on you, vs. just teasing you out of boredom?"

8 - "i bet its a real annoyance knowing that its the democrats who are championing community colleges, which keeps tuition and instructor pay so low"

7 - "so is there any real correlation between grades and income, for someone who graduates with a BA in english literature? i mean, does wal-mart actually care?"

6 - "i know this great web site where you can see every term paper written on beowolf ever written. you should check it out - i bet you could find a lot of the other students in class are like plagiarizing from there"

5 - "you know its such a cliche to drive a saab. they don't even get good mileage."

4 - "so did you read the corrections? no? being an english professor, i thought you would have. its a national book award winner about an english professor who has a mental breakdown. its really great"

3 - "you know, the opportunities to quote shakespeare in the workplace are minimal. its really kind of useless to have us memorize these passages."

2 - "we can't understand what your teaching assistant is saying in class - he's from tragedystan or someplace, i think. his accent is awful. anyway, we're all getting bad grades, and if you flunk us we're all going to the dean and complain because his accent is so bad."

1 - "at least you have the satisfaction of loving your job, even if you're underpaid" (most don't actually love their jobs, or have tenure)

Re: top 10 things to say to professors
by IncogNeato

Love #7. Relate to #2. Only it was the professor, not the aide.

Re: "he's a professor"
by Khaki

Maybe they ordered this "Genius In A Box" kit, it's hard to resist, what with the "I'm Super Smart" cape and all....

:)

View as RSS news feed in XML