The Fray
XX Factor
Campaign 2008
News & Politics
Arts & Life
Business & Tech
Health & Science
Style & Shopping
Travel & Food
Sports
Slate
on NPR
NEWSLETTERS
PODCASTS
RSS
enter the fray:
our reader discussion forum
The Fray
XX Factor
Was that "Ha ha" funny?
Sign in
Search in:
All forums
XX Factor
Advanced
View:
Flat
Threaded
scrutinizing the "Christianitiness" of the wrong songs
by
ghost
05/22/2008, 4:43 PM
#
Reply
This shows how little the author was paying attention and the astounding chasm of ignorance she demonstrated with respect to Christianity. At least four in a row of Cook's songs were songs that are heavy on religious undertones. One group is an explicitly Christian group (Switchfoot). Two of the others have huge Christian followings because of the very recognizably christian messages of their songs (U2, Collective Soul). The fourth song I didn't recognize, but it seemed to have some lyrics about faith.
Report abuse
Re: scrutinizing the "Christianitiness" of the wrong songs
by
duhwayne
05/22/2008, 5:15 PM
#
Reply
Adding to that the fact that there are multiple clips on youtube of Archuleta singing the entire song, and that he explained himself that he only had time for one and liked the third verse of the utterly Marxist tune best. It's amazing how much mileage the LA times blogger got out of poor speculation based on the fact that Archuleta is Mormon. For God's sakes.
Report abuse
Re: scrutinizing the "Christianitiness" of the wrong songs
by
ArtemisMS
05/22/2008, 6:17 PM
#
Reply
For gods sakes. It's supposed to be a funny article!
Report abuse
Was that "Ha ha" funny?
by
ghost
05/23/2008, 11:11 AM
#
Reply
As in "ha ha" funny, or weird funny? Yes, she was attempting to be tongue-in-cheek, but the least she can do is imbue her facetious analogy with a modicum of plausibility. But instead the article falls flat and justifiably reaps derision.
Report abuse