Surprise, surprise: Plotz is wrong
by
marcparis
05/18/2008, 12:06 PM #
OK, there's a correction up. But that doesn't change the fact that Plotz based his entire argument on one of the three Gabfest topics, same-sex marriage in California, on a "fact" that was the complete opposite of reality. The state legislature voted IN FAVOR of same-sex marriage, not AGAINST.
And of course Emily was wrong in not knowing that the 2000 initiative reserved marriage to opposite-sex couples. But unlike Plotz, she didn't hang her argument on her error.
Get rid of Plotz!