Re: The problem for Obama is that
by
The Way
04/23/2008, 1:13 AM #
Austin,
Again, your ad hominem attacks make it rather hard to take you seriously. Is it possible to have a reasoned political debate without resorting to base insults anymore? I never even mentioned whether I am a supporter of Obama or Clinton; I just happen to love politics (enough so that I've essentially dedicated my life to the study of it). I do support Obama now as it has become clear that he will be the nominee of my party, but that (hopefully) doesn't prevent objective analysis of the situation.
There have yet to be any major, comprehensive polls dealing with a McCain - Obama race, and even had such polling taken place they'd be of little value given the fact that the Democratic primaries are ongoing which would dramatically impact such poll results. There have been some polls gauging possible outcomes of a McCain/Obama and a McCain/Clinton matchup (available at realclearpolitics.com) and the most recent show Obama beating McCain by little more than a percent and McCain beating Clinton by substantially less than one percent. It, of cource, should be noted that both of these results are statistical ties given the margin of error, and again rather useless because the continued Democratic primaries are too much of an interfering influence.
As for demographics, I'm not really seeing your argument. Again, there is no logical reason to assume that individuals who prefer Clinton to Obama will also, necessarily, prefer McCain. In fact, that is rather counterintuitive, at least if you believe that the majority of individuals vote according to candidate's stances on the issues. I'm curious as to your logic, perhaps if you better explained your position I'd understand.
Now, I wouldn't be surprised if a majority of Hispanics voted for McCain in November, but that's because historically Hispanics have tended to support the Republican party. McCain's stance on immigration should further help to maintain this support (the Repulican Party's anti-immigration policies have been a major driver of recent growing support for Democrats among Hispanic populations, but McCain isn't with his party on this particular issue). This would be the case regardless of whether or not Clinton or Obama wins the nomination.
As for white blue-collar workers, why do you assume that they'd support McCain over Obama when they traditionally support the Democratic candidate? Past demographic voting patterns would suggest that they will vote Democratic regardless of who wins the nomination. Unions will certainly come out in support of the Democratic Party and, while union members don't necessarily vote according to their Union's endorsement, this is indicative of the general trend.
McCain has a lot of baggage and faces many obstacles, not the least of which is a fractured Republican Party (a fact that has gained little attention of late, but which is very real). Indeed, today McCain only won 72% of the vote in Pennsylvania's Republcan primary and he has already won the nomination. While no hard conclusions can be drawn from this, it does seem to imply that McCain has yet to be successful in consolidating his support within his own party. It is unclear how this will develop and play out over the coming months.
Finally, it is rather naive to make any hard predictions about the outcome in November. A lot can and will happen between now and then. One of the candidates on either side could make a huge mistake and turn the tide solidly against them. Iraq could grow significantly worse, or improve. Same with the economy. Electoral predictions are only really useful in the short-term when it is relatively reasonable to assume there won't be a major change in the status quo. How will the election play out in November? I don't know, nor do you. We'll both have to wait and see.