Go to Ask.com


enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by Usama2

While I am not an expert on the religious laws of the 3 Abrahamic faiths, it is my understanding that all 3 oppose eating land animals that are carnivores. At least the Jewish and Islamic religious laws forbid this. I estimate that the more orthodox Christian denomitations would agree.

In this sense, the religious text reenforce and hold up the more recent medical justification. Carnivores eat raw meat, including meat which contains diseases and parasites which can possibly be passed on to humans.

More specifically,-sorry for the graphic depictions- dogs have a highly versatile pallet, including eating their own vomit, feces of other animals such as cats, carrion, garbage of all kinds including human feces (baby diapers included).

Thus, consuming carnivores such as dogs is a violation of the Jewish, Islamic, and at least the Orthodox Christian tradition. So the onus to avoid consuming Fido when living paycheck to paycheck has higher origins than just one's conscience: God said DON'T.

BTW, God also said be kind to your neighbors, so pick up that poop so we don't reconsider Pooch ala Mode. ;)

Re: Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by JonFrum

That same God also said don't eat lobster.

Moron.

Re: Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by dogeater
If god didn't want us to eat certain things why the hell did he make those things taste so damn good. So the hell with what god thinks.
Re: Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by TaoistPhD
And since GOD is all powerful and all knowing if HE was really interested in us not eating HIS other creations HE would provide us with alternatives.
Re: Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by Planetary Eulogy

TaoistPhD:
And since GOD is all powerful and all knowing if HE was really interested in us not eating HIS other creations HE would provide us with alternatives.

Why do you think He gave us aborted fetuses? Duh.

Re: Pooch ala Mode Against Abrahamic Faiths
by Usama2

Well, I am not impartial regarding God's laws to mankind. I converted from Christianity to Islam, and Islam permits eating creatures of the sea such as crusteceans.

And if one considers that God's Law to Moses for the tribes of Israel was superceded by God's Law to Muhammad for all of mankind until the end of time, then one should consider that God said it is ok now for you to eat lobsters.

As for calling God a moron, how now? Or was that for me?

View as RSS news feed in XML