Re: Superdelegate Primary
by
SalientMan
03/26/2008, 7:48 PM #
I might be in favor of a superdelegate primary...but how would that work? Would the supers all have to go cast an anonymous ballot and then we'd have Price-Waterhouse-Coopers tally the results and tell us who won? Could be the political version of the Oscars.
But what would happen then? Would the votes translate into delegates, like a state convention? So it would be like adding a 51st state? And then the delegates from that primary...would they be free to change their minds like other delegates?
The big problem I would have if the hypothetical "superdelegate primary" was a secret ballot would be that it would turn the ballot box into the smoke-filled room of yore. Picture this scenario: the supers all cast ballots, and it turns out that Hillary wins by a massive margin. Obama fans in Obama-leaning states are outraged, but their representatives and senators and governors all say, "Don't look at me! I voted for him!" Clearly, some are lying, but nobody knows who. The result is, some supers probably get voted out of office for suspicion of having "sided with the enemy" even though they didn't, and some who would otherwise have been in political trouble for voting the way they did get off scot-free.
But if it would be more of a superdelegate caucus, I could go for that...