enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Re: The Wire & No Country For Old Men
by Sasha

Shawn,

I somewhat disagree with your view of McCarthty. Moss is not done in by his own moral failure - the very confusion surrounding his killing shows that violence can strike seemingly without reason. That violence is an inescapable natural force is a major theme in all of McCarthy's works.

Sheriff Bell, unlike Bunk, is not vital "in the long run." He is, in fact, irrelevant. His impotence underscores how man-made moral law is itself impotent to stop something like an Anton Chigurh, (or, to go back to another McCarthy book, a Judge Holden), each a demonstration of how human violence is permanent and in the end unstoppable.

That being said, I agree that what it boils down to is "a glimmer of hope," that, in the view of both Simon and McCarthy, being the best the world can hope for.

View complete thread