So you currently have SS payments to retirees coming from money that is deducted from paychecks. If you stop making those deductions so you can start this new market fund, who pays current retirees?

If everyone is going to be allowed to put their money into the market, who selects the funds they can put money in? Who manages those funds?

The reason there was no interest in Bush's plan is that he didn't have a plan. He had a bumper sticker.