How is that hypocritical? You've never read something that, when you got done, you found to be idiotic, then remarked that it was idiotic? I'm not going to say something is idiotic w/out actually reading it.

If I go to a movie that halfway through seems like it won't be good, but I sit through the whole thing, and then say that movie sucked and wasn't worth viewing, am I being a hypocrite?