enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Re: Why he's awful
by The Real Slim K
I'm not entirely sure how we got onto the subject of "A Catcher in the Rye" but I have to agree with theylyamhound. Holden is not just a regular doofus adolescent, I think most people laugh at his use of slang/language, not entirely wrong criticisms of society and others such as Old-Stradlater or Ackley, and feel some genuine sympathy for him in his relationships with his sister and deceased brother Allie, and ex-girlfriend Jane. I think a major point--to doubt and question adults, is spot on as the Brits say. You see a similar theme to almost every "Southpark" episodes, "adults lie to us all the time." How can anyone who wants to be taken seriously, mmmm, argue with that statement?
View complete thread