As a long-time, Boulder, Colorado resident, I can say that not every guy finds athletic women unappealing. People in this part of the world work out in a variety of ways. World-class althletes train here. I can say for sure that an in-shape, althletic woman is still considered a hottie. Plus, and call me a sexist pig if you will, but confident athletes tend to show it off a bit more, which makes the boys happy :)