Go to Ask.com


enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Re: Fetal separation: Mr. Saletan's logic fails
by DBuss

You don't have the right to compel me to provide the function of my kidneys for your benefit, but the state might...

I'm reasonably sure the state *doesn't* have that right, especially when we're talking about applying it to non-criminals. Slavery is against the Constitution, ditto Cruel and Unusual, and I've never heard of any State running around taking people kidneys.

View complete thread