@ Lalex:
The Great American Propaganda Machine (GAPM) is maintained not just by the
news/information media but also by the entertainment industry and the K-12
school system. It is now an all-pervasive and self-sustaining part of our
culture. The GAPM perpetuates a national self-delusion increasingly detached
from reality. If America were a person, the prescription would be a potent
anti-psychotic.
The very heart of the self-delusion seems to revolve around the concept of
American exceptionalism. This, in turn, has is roots in the revolutionary
origins of the nation. On 1776 July 4 the union of the 13 American colonies into
a democratic republic was an exceptional event in world
history. But when in 1862 Abraham Lincoln proclaimed America to be "the
last, best hope of earth" one has to question what he was talking
about.
By 1862 the Enlightment ideas that had been embodied in the new American
republic had caught up to the rest of the world. The British Empire had
abolished the slave trade in 1807 and slave ownership in 1834. In 1862 America
was playing catch-up to its once reactionary parent. Just five years later
Britain's remaining colonies in North America peacefully united to form another
enduring democracy on this continent. In 1862 the only thing exceptional about
America was the sheer magnitude of the carnage it was inflicting upon
itself.
The Industrial Revolution gave birth to the world's first global superpower,
Great Britain. Our northern neighbor stretches from the Atlantic to the Pacific
only by virtue of the British technology that went into Canada's
transcontinental railroad completed in 1885. By the end of Queen Victoria's
reign in 1901 it was Great Britain, not the United States, that bestrode the
world like a colossus.
It took two calamities to bring Great Britain to her knees, two catastrophic
wars conveniently designated with the indices one and two. By the end of World
War II, the torch of global hegemony had passed from Great Britain to the United
States. The passing of this torch also marked the birth of the Great American
Propaganda Machine (GAPM).
To illustrate the GAPM in action, consider the standard American version of
World War II in Europe. In the account of New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd,
America didn't hesitate to stand up to Hitler and we crushed his armies
following our invasion of Normandy. This borders on pure fiction. Two years
passed between Hitler's invasion of Poland that ignited the war in 1939 and
America's forced entry into the war by Japan's attack on Pearl
Harbor in 1941. Shortly after that attack, it was Germany who declared war on
America, not the other way around.
Another three years passed before five allied armies
converged on the Normandy beaches, two of which were American.
By the time of the Normandy invasion in June 1944, Germany had effectively lost
the war. In early 1943 the German 6th Army was annihilated by the Soviet Red
Army at Stalingrad. In the summer of 1943, the Red Army broke through the German
defensive line at the Battle of Kursk, the largest tank battle in history. That
battle initiated the rout of the German forces that sealed the fate of Hitler's
Third Reich.
By the time that two American, two British, and one Canadian army had landed
at Normandy on the Western Front, the Russians on the Eastern Front were pushing
the Germans back deep into Poland. The Germans threw almost everything they had
at the advancing Russians. In the climactic Battle of Berlin the Russians killed
half a million Germans in one of the bloodiest battles of the war. German loses
in that final battle exceeded American loses in all of World
War II.
While the Battle of Berlin was raging, the allies on the Western Front were
advancing through German-occupied territory virtually unopposed. After Normandy,
there was only one memorable battle on the Western Front, a desperate German
counter-offensive that only pushed a bulge into the allied line. If casualties
are any indication, then it is fair to say that Hitler was defeated by the
Soviet Union on the Eastern Front and that the Allied Western Front was a
sideshow. <link>
This, of course, is not the account of the war in Europe that has entered
American popular culture. Franklin Roosevelt is still being blamed for ceding
Eastern Europe to Stalin at Yalta as if the Battles of Stalingrad, Kursk, and
Berlin had been fought and won by Leprechauns. More on this later.
Wars naturally give rise to propaganda and the victors get to write the
history books. What is unique about World War II is that the end of the war
marked the beginning of a peacetime propaganda offensive, the GAPM, that has
never stopped. America, victorious over Japan and Germany, was now the "most
powerful nation on earth", its president the self-appointed "leader of
the free world" in possession of the most fearsome weapons of mass
destruction ever devised and with a demonstrated willingness to use them.
While America was basking in its new status as a global superpower, the
Soviet occupation of Eastern Europe provoked a "Red Scare" that evolved into the
Cold War. This kicked the GAPM into high gear. Ideological differences assumed a
Manichean dimension with God-fearing America pitted in a life-or-death moral
struggle with godless communism. The motto of our nation was changed from "E
Pluribus Unum" to "In God We Trust". The words "under
God" were added to the Pledge of Allegiance. Lincoln's expression
"last, best hope for earth" was interpreted to mean that America had a
divine mission not just to defend but to propagate American values with
missionary zeal.
This propaganda offensive achieved Orwellian proportions on 1947 September 18
when the Department of War was renamed the Department of Defense. Now America
could wield its fearsome military machine with impunity if done in the cause of
righteousness. The righteousness part came easily. America's growing material
prosperity was testament enough to God's blessing of America. The only fly in
the ointment was that America itself was riven by a bitter partisan dispute over
the causes and remedies for inequality, a dispute that ironically, and in
different contexts, had originally given rise to communist and fascist
ideologies in Europe.
The time was exactly ripe for the rise of a demagogue who would ruthlessly
exploit the GAPM in partisan attacks against fellow Americans. Joseph McCarthy
now makes his entrance from the right and occupies center stage. McCarthy was
one of those who blamed Roosevelt for being "soft" on communism at Yalta. Note
well the tactic that was developed here by McCarthy. First the GAPM is used to
present a narrative that is distorted out of any resemblance to reality. Then
the narrator wraps himself in the flag and uses his distorted narrative as a
cudgel to bash his Democratic opponent as being an unpatriotic traitor. This
tactic was perfected by Joseph McCarthy and has remained in the Republican box
of dirty tactics ever since.
The exploitation of the GAPM as a partisan weapon is so successful
that leftist critics of American politics and policy like Noam Chomsky and Rev.
Jeremiah Wright, to name just two, can be completely shut out of the mainstream
political discussion. Meanwhile, there isn't an idea too outrageous for wingnuts
like Rush Limbaugh and Ann Coulter to express as long as their ravings are
wrapped in the flag. The flag itself, once a revered symbol of the nation, has
become just another partisan weapon, desecrated by those who literally wear
their "patriotism" on their lapel.
So is there a remedy for this toxic mess that threatens our democracy? Yes
there is. The remedy is called leadership. Barack Obama's life experiences have
given him a uniquely broad perspective on America. Well, unique among the field
of presidential aspirants that we saw in January. Obama's perspective is broad
enough that he can clearly see the GAPM for what it is and the threat it poses.
If Obama is serious about bringing conservatives and liberals together to
address the causes and remedies for inequality, then the distorting filter of
the GAPM has got to go.
The great American physicist Richard Feynman put it succinctly: "Nature
will not be fooled." As an engineer and a problem-solver, I would phrase it
this way: To solve a problem you have to understand the problem. The GAPM, not
being reality-based, is an obstacle to understanding. Because it has come to
pervade and distort every aspect of our culture, especially our perception of
who we are as a people, the GAPM can be a huge obstacle to
understanding.
As I have been critical of the presumption of Lincoln's "last, best hope
for earth" characterization of America, I will conclude with another
passage from that same State of the Union address: "The dogmas of the quiet
past are inadequate to the stormy present. The occasion is piled high with
difficulty, and we must rise with the occasion. As our case is new, so we must
think anew and act anew. We must disenthrall ourselves, and then we shall save
our country."