I don't consider myself overtly superficial. But I am picky. For example, there are quite a few people who I LOVE to talk to, but that doesn't mean that I'd want to sleep with them. In other words, they are good for a mental roll in the hay but not a real life one.

I am not attracted to fat people, no matter how awesome their minds are. I don't think that's necessarily being superficial, it's just knowing your limits. And the idea of 300 lbs of flesh on top of me is definitely NOT a turn on!