Go to Ask.com


enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Aw, gee...
by schuylercat

You wrecked the surprise. Sniff.

I have a theory. Whenever Slate concocts a new letter for Prudie, the "I'm with the greatest guy/girl ever" letter uses two superlatives:

"...He's the greatest, most wonderful..."

"...She's the most beautiful and intelligent..."

"...He's the most handsome, well-endowed..."

Seems to happen every time.

Now, I wouldn't want to say, you know, that these letters are, well, shall we say made up or anything (yes, I would) but the formula is becoming tired, and I think we should complain - loudly and bitterly - to them about finding a new letter writer.

You think our esteemed Emily Yoffee herself writes them? There's no clear flow in style between the letters and her responses, so I long suspected they were handed to her, but frankly I haven't read her responses in so long I can't tell. I don't "read" Dear Prudie any more - I read the letters, take a few Vicodin with a double Beefeaters on the rocks with two bis olives, read them again, then I look for you, August, Messy or one of my beholden for the answers.

And so: having said that, I think you're perfect! I will send Slate a request that YOU become the new ghost letter writer for Dear Prudie! Do you want the job? Please say yes. We need change here. Will you? Will you?

View complete thread