Let's say I'm alone on a desert island with a painting. I say the painting is beautiful. Then I die. Is the painting still beautiful?

Suppose there's this child molester who's after this six year old. Why? Because he says six year olds are totally hot? Would you say the six year old exhibits hotness?

What we're talking about here are properly called subjective evaluations. Not properties. Evaluations are mental constructs. They live in your brain and not outside it. Is 5 a better number or is three the better number? It's nonsense. They're neither good nor bad. Goodness and badness are not properties of things. They're evaluations created by your brain.