enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Scientists are idiots
by tracker

Of course everyone, even in America!, is aware of the investigatory power science took on as soon as adopted a guess and test approach to acquiring information and generating theories. What the wizards writing here seem to completely miss is that Americans have terrific doubts about individual humans because of what they know about human nature, which includes scientists and their susceptibility to group-think, pride, deceit, stubbornness, unquestioned ideological commitments, etc.

... some examples.

Climate change is a classic "Americans are anti-science" boner. Americans are mainly theists. They think God might have something to say about the fate of the world. Shocking! So, science wizards, ... when one specialist is yakking it up on Nat Geo about the utter unlikelihood that earth would form, get a blast of nickel from colliding with the moon, ... just enough to keep the core molten and the earth the right temp for life, ... and in so arguing conclude the opposite of the last 10 years of Nat Geo telling us earth type planets are probably common and life abundant in the universe, is it any wonder Americans, who pay attention pretty well, have to wonder what happens to science-minded people when they have no philosophical training ... no ideological outlook that isn't tossed about by every new discovery? They conclude scientists have no idea what to think about the world. They're overspecialized, under philosophized.
Re: Scientists are idiots
by Loki's Curse

This screed reminds me of student compositions I have read. I write a comment something like: "I'm sure you have some good ideas here. Why don't you think about what you want to communicate, and take another look at it."

Long live the Empire!

View as RSS news feed in XML