enter the fray: our reader discussion forum
Search in:
Advanced
View:FlatThreaded
Piano colada
by robusto

My only question to you, Chris, is where have you been for the last, oh, dozen years? In 1997 I bought an 88-key Roland digital piano that has hammer-action keys and sounds really good when you unplug the built-in speakers and play it through my sound system. Yeah, it doesn't have all the bells and whistles of the AvantGrand, but all that shaking and what have you probably add, I would guess, about one or two percent to the verisimilitude. In about a minute I forgot I wasn't playing on my old crappy spinet.

And it does have a few bells and whistles of its own. I can adjust the apparent key resistance, and choose among several instrument combinations (a big bright grand like a Steinway, a "soft" grand like a Bechstein, a honky-tonk piano, an electric), including some terrible synth strings. The pedals work fine and I have been plunking away happily for years on it. (Yeah, even butchered some Rachmaninoff on it, too, which was never even possible on the spinet.)

The point is, you didn't have to wait for Yamaha to "perfect" the digital piano. Going from a PSO (a "piano-shaped object," which basically describes just about any home-kept piano) to a decent digital is such a big step up that it's been an obvious choice for a lot of people for years. So Yamaha's digital isn't really new, and it isn't really news. If I were in the market to switch at the moment I'd surely consider it, but I get so much out of my current instrument that I couldn't justify the cost. And unless your playing is an order of magnitude or so better than mine, your skill probably wouldn't justify the extra cost, either.

Re: Piano colada
by viretarmis

Agreed Robusto: I bought a Yamaha digital for under $1200. (That's hundreds, not thousands) and it delivers as promised. Three piano emulations plus harpsichord, weighted keys, touch sensitive and always in tune. And when we need to dust or vacuum, the wife and I pick it up and move it without problem.

Its tone has fooled many listeners (including musicians) who swear it sounds "like a real piano" . The joke is that of course, it is - just as real as the images on your TV or the script on your computer screen.

Maybe Yamaha could arrange a blind test of its AvantGard versus some middling Steinway and silence its critics.

Re: Piano colada
by sftroybob
I picked up their YPG-625 a couple years ago, now out for under $700, and it's damn awesome. The high-end stuff might be great for a Beethoven, but if you're not a Beethoven you don't need it.
View as RSS news feed in XML